18 de julio de 2019
Hispanic World

Supreme Court analyzing Census citizenship question

Laura Barros

Laura Barros

Washington, Apr 23 (efe-epa).- The controversy over the inclusion of a question on citizenship on the 2020 US Census went to the Supreme Court on Tuesday amid the shouts of opponents gathered outside the judicial seat and the positions of the magistrates.

The nine high court justices, five conservatives and four progressives, listened for about 80 minutes to arguments for and against the citizenship question, which has not been included on Censuses since 1950 and has been rejected by federal courts in California, New York and Maryland.

US Solicitor General Noel Francisco, who is tasked with defending the government of President Donald Trump in the courts, argued in favor of including the question proposed in March 2018 by Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross.

Local media reported that Francisco said that Ross, despite understanding the negatives that the question could entail, came to the conclusion that the benefits of including the question in next year's count of all persons in the US outweighed the costs.

However, Justice Sonia Sotomayor, one of the progressives on the high court and the lone Hispanic, replied that "The enumeration is how many people reside here, not how many are citizens. That's what the census survey is supposed to figure out."

Sotomayor said that "nobody doubts" that asking about respondents' citizenship will reduce Census response rates, adding that Hispanics - in particular - have "a legitimate fear" of immigration authorities and calling the citizenship question "a solution in search of a problem."

A study by the Office of the Census found that at least 6.5 million people would not participate in the Census if a question about their citizenship were to be included.

Press reports indicate that the conservative magistrates on the court are inclined to allow the inclusion of the controversial question.

Outside the Supreme Court, pro-immigrant activists - most of them Hispanics - protested against including the question.

"The Constitution says to count everyone, not just citizens," read one of the signs displayed by the roughly 100 protesters awaiting the close of the high court session, and representatives from Asian communities demanded that they not be made "invisible," which they claimed such a question would do by discouraging their members from participation in the Census.

"That's a question that is racist, it's manipulative, they're using something that's sacred such as civil rights to justify a racist question," Gustavo Torres told EFE.

Torres warned that the "basic aim" is to eliminate 6.5 million people from the Census, a move - in his judgment - that could affect vital matters such as the distribution of federal resources and the allocation of seats in the House of Representatives.

"The reason why it's so important that people let themselves be counted is because here in this country that information is used every 10 years to assign funds for the next 10 years that go for education, for healthcare, for housing, for recreation for our families," he added.

Meanwhile, Cataliza Aristizabal, the co-director of the Make the Road New York organization, emphasized the importance of the Census in determining legislative representation.

"For New York, which is a very populous state, we could lose up to two representatives in the lower house if they don't count everyone," she warned.

People from various other sectors in California, Arizona, Florida, Illinois and Texas have expressed themselves along the same lines.

Aristizabal said that this "is a change" for the Census, but in addition "it's another tactic of this administration, which has been very anti-immigrant."

Histórico de noticias
Eden Pastora: Leaders-turned-dissidents derailed Nicaraguan revolution

By Luis Felipe Palacios

US House votes to hold AG Barr, Commerce Sect. Ross in contempt

Washington, Jul 17 (efe-epa).- The House of Representatives on Wednesday voted to hold Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross and US Attorney General William Barr...

Bolivia's Torrez hopes she'll win Pan Am swimming medal in Lima

By Yolanda Salazar

Serra Pelada: 40 years of gold fever that devastated the Amazon jungle

By Alba Santandreu

Brazil promises to keep alive Mercosur's push that garnered EU pact

By Natalia Kidd

5 Killed in drug rehab center in western Mexico

Mexico City, Jul 17 (efe-epa).- Five men were shot and killed at a drug rehabilitation center in Morelia, capital of the western Mexican state of Michoacan,...

Guatemalan migrants return from US with complaints re treatment in shelters

By Emiliano Castro Saenz

Ecuadorian women scientists slam gender gap in their profession

By Christian A. Sanchez

Trump refuses to criticize Turkey after Ankara buys Russian missiles

Washington, Jul 16 (EFE).- President Donald Trump on Tuesday refused to criticize the Turkish government of Recep Tayyip Erdogan after the Pentagon blocked...

Los Angeles, Jul 16 (epa-efe).- "Game of Thrones" on Tuesday racked up a record 32 Emmy Award nominations, thus becoming the series that has received the...

Mexican nature preserve could take 200 years to recover from fire damage

By Lourdes Cruz

Paraguay taxi drivers again at war with Uber

Asuncion, Jul 16 (efe-epa).- Hundreds of taxi drivers suspended their service this Tuesday to again drive through the streets of Asuncion with a long...

Dried-up Aculeo Lagoon shows the woes of climate change in Chile

By Alberto Peña

Trump doubles down on tweets against Democratic congresswomen

By Lucia Leal.

Princess Mako thanks Bolivia for 120 years welcoming Japanese migrants

La Paz, Jul 15 (efe-epa).- Princess Mako of Japan thanked Bolivia this Monday for the welcome it has extended over the past 120 years to Japanese migrants...

Mexico rules out being safe third country for migrants despite Trump's order

Mexico City, Jul 15 (efe-epa).- Mexican Foreign Secretary Marcelo Ebrard on Monday ruled out that his country would become a "safe third country" for...

Salvadoran woman charged with abortion says she is innocent

Ciudad Delgado, El Salvador, Jul 15 (efe-epa).- Twenty-one-year-old Salvadoran Evelyn Hernandez said Monday that she is innocent of aggravated murder for...

Billionaire Buffett's real estate unit joins forces with Spain's LARVIA

New York, Jul 15 (efe-epa).- Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices, the real estate unit of billionaire Warren Buffett's Berkshire Hathaway Inc. conglomerate,...

Residents of historic Panama neighborhood fight gentrification

By Maria M.Mur.

Pressure mounts for Puerto Rico governor's resignation amid scandal

San Juan, Jul 15 (efe-epa).- Pressure is mounting in Puerto Rico for Gov. Ricardo Rossello to resign after the revelation of the contents of private online...

Trump says tariffs taking a toll on China's economy

Washington, Jul 15 (efe-epa).- President Donald Trump said Monday that the tariffs imposed by his administration were taking a toll on China's economy,...

Barry weakens over Louisiana, but flooding alert remains in place

Washington, Jul 14 (efe-epa).- Tropical Storm Barry weakened to a tropical depression as it crossed the state of Louisiana on Sunday, heading...

San Juan Parangaricutiro, Mexico's Pompeii buried by Paricutin volcano

By Manuel Soberanes Cobo

Khya, a baby kangaroo being raised by humans in western Mexican city

By Mariana Gonzalez